Mental Health in the Workplace

There has been an undeniable shift in the need to address mental health in the workplace. Employees more universally expect mental health benefits from their jobs, and employers increasingly recognize that offering high-quality mental health programs is the right thing to do—both for their people and their business. Today, supporting mental health at work is a business necessity.

The number of people seeking mental health support is on the rise. Almost half of American workers are coping with a mental health issue, yet getting care is difficult. Long wait times, a shortage of mental health providers, high out-of-pocket fees, and poor care quality are just a few roadblocks along the path to care.

When employees lack access to needed mental health care, they’re less likely to work effectively and more likely to seek pricey medical care that may not address their needs. Employers bear the financial weight of under-treated mental health conditions, often without realizing it.

How prevalent are mental health issues in the workplace?

Mental health concerns are universal. Whether it’s stress or burnout, anxiety or depression, most of us will face mental health challenges at some point.

One in five people worldwide experiences a diagnosable mental health disorder each year. In the United States alone, over 51 million adults are struggling. Even more people—76 percent, according to one study—reported at least one symptom of a mental disorder in the past year.

Millennials and Gen Zers, along with LGBTQ+, Black, and Latinx employees, face unique mental health challenges. BIPOC communities have been forced to live in survival mode to endure systemic oppression. They have also had less access and ability to afford mental health services. These groups may be impacted disproportionately by stigma against discussing mental health at work as well as factors like discrimination and harassment.

The most common mental illnesses in the U.S. are anxiety and depression, followed by post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), dual diagnosis (having more than one mental health disorder), and bipolar disorder. Additionally, burnout—a form of chronic workplace stress—has affected workers on a global scale. Burnout is one of the top 3 mental health issues affecting U.S. employees according to our survey.

Despite mental illness being so widespread, more than half of those affected go without the care they need.

What negatively impacts workplace mental health?

While being employed promotes well-being, a negative working environment can lead to mental health issues. Employee mental health in the workplace can be impacted by many things, including work environment and company culture. Here are some of the factors that can negatively impact workforce mental health:

Signs employees are struggling with mental health at work

Since managers often interact daily with their team, they’re well-positioned to recognize when an employee may be struggling with mental health concerns and to help connect them to available resources.

Mental health conditions can present differently in different people. Some employees may show several signs that they are struggling while others may show few, making it hard to identify that they have a problem. Stigma keeps many people silent even if they know they need support.

This is why it’s important for managers to know how to spot mental health issues at work, be proactive about identifying the need for support, and create an environment where employees feel safe to discuss their mental health and workplace concerns. Managers aren’t expected to be therapists, but being able to identify potential issues is a critical first step in supporting workplace mental health.

Anxiety and depression are among the most common mental health disorders in the workforce.

Here are a few signs of anxiety and depression that may be observable at work:

Employees may be struggling with a wide range of other mental health issues – from stress to schizophrenia – and each of these issues has unique symptoms. Generally speaking, signs of distress can include:

If you notice signs of distress in your employee, avoid jumping to the conclusion that mental illness is the cause. Many mental health symptoms can also be signs of other issues, such as physical illnesses or even medication side effects. The most helpful approach is a private, empathetic conversation about what you’re seeing and asking how you can help.

How mental health disorders affect employees

Mental health is an essential part of overall health. Most people will face some type of mental health challenge in their lifetime—either directly or indirectly—that may make it difficult to function their best at work.

Mental health conditions can have far-reaching effects on employees, including:

Increased risk of physical illness

Mental illness is associated with several health problems, including heart disease and diabetes. Yet medical professionals often have difficulty recognizing and treating mental conditions. Stigma and cost also prevent people from getting the right treatment. As a result, health care costs are higher for people with depression and other mental illnesses.

Shorter life expectancy

In addition to poorer physical health, suicides and accidents contribute to a higher death rate in people with mental health disorders.

Lost income

People with depression, for example, are five times more likely to become unemployed than those without depression.

Higher rates of disability

Depression can interfere with people’s ability to complete physical job tasks and reduces cognitive performance.

Lower overall life satisfaction

Largely due to stigma, people with mental illness are more likely to suffer from low self-esteem and have less social support, which affects their overall sense of well-being.

How employee mental health affects companies

Why is employee mental health in the workplace a business concern?

Your people are your greatest asset, and their mental health impacts every aspect of their lives, including their work. Many are struggling, and employers can help. Plus, the cost of mental health to your organization is too high to ignore.

Untreated mental illness impacts companies through:

Lost productivity

The World Health Organization (WHO) has found that mental health affects work performance, with lost productivity due to depression and anxiety alone costing the global economy $1 trillion each year.

So, how does mental health affect work performance? Those with depressive symptoms are seven times as likely to experience “decreased effectiveness” at work than peers without depression. They’re also more likely to struggle with time management, mental functioning, and interpersonal communication, resulting in less work output overall.

Higher health care costs

Employees with untreated mental illnesses are six times as likely to visit the ER compared to the general population. There are significant gaps in access to in-network mental health care providers, meaning that employees must either forego treatment or turn to pricey out-of-network care or medical visits that fail to address underlying needs.

More disability claims

Without effective treatment, working can become too difficult for people with mental health disorders, and they may need to leave their job. In fact, over one-third of disability claims are tied to mental health conditions.

Higher turnover

Fifty percent of millennial and 75 percent of Generation Z workers reported having left a job in 2019 due at least in part to mental health reasons. In an increasingly competitive labor market, businesses that aren’t addressing mental health in the workforce risk getting left behind. Most employees (80 percent) today say that, when considering a new job, it’s at least somewhat important to them that the prospective employer offers mental health benefits.

Employers are ideally situated to help address employee mental health in the workplace. Many businesses already have programs, policies, and support networks in place that can be tailored to promote employee well-being. And employers can track progress and measure the effects of these efforts.

The value of comprehensive mental health support

Leading companies are increasingly offering mental health benefits to support their employees.

This is, in part, because treatment works. According to the National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI), the treatment efficacy for mental illness exceeds the rates for heart disease.

Treatment is also cost-effective. According to the WHO, every U.S. dollar invested in treatment yields a return of $4 in improved health and productivity. Employers that invest in a comprehensive mental health benefit see significant cost savings in the following areas:

Health plan costs

Organizations that offer Lyra spend significantly less on medical claims for members who use Lyra than those who get care through their health plans, according to a report from professional services firm Aon.

*Based on 9.2% utilization rate, Source: Lyra Health Cost Efficiency Analysis, Aon

Employee turnover

High-quality mental health benefits drive employee retention, which translates into savings for hiring and training new employees. Employees who use a comprehensive mental health benefit like Lyra are almost twice as likely to stay with the company as those who don’t use it.

Absenteeism and presenteeism

Both absenteeism (unplanned absence) and presenteeism (being on the job but not fully functional due to an underlying health condition) are detrimental to employee productivity.

Therapy and medication have been shown to be effective at addressing mental health symptoms and helping people regain their footing at work, thereby reducing absenteeism and presenteeism. Almost 86 percent of employees treated for depression report improved work performance.

Lyra’s research echoes these findings—70 percent of members in the clinical range who seek care with Lyra show improved productivity levels on the Work Limitation Questionnaire (WLQ) index measure.

How to improve mental health in the workplace

One of managers’ most important roles is to support their team members—including their mental health. Since people spend about one-third of their lives at work, even small changes at the company level can make a big difference.

Here are a few ways employers can help promote mental health in the workplace:

Combat stigma

Employers play an important role in destigmatizing mental illness and nurturing a positive work environment. Take proactive steps to combat stigma, such as encouraging open discussion around mental health at work, doing regular check-ins and surveys, and developing anti-stigma programs.

Be a role model

Take care of yourself and be transparent about the ways you’re doing so. When managers and company leaders talk openly about their mental health, they send a message to employees that they are welcome to discuss their own challenges as well.

Foster a culture of connection

Social connection enhances people’s resilience to stress. Create a culture of connection by implementing peer support groups and employee resource groups (ERGs). Just as isolation and feeling “other” can be enemies of mental health, nurturing casual interactions where teammates get to know one another as people helps build trust.

Develop education programs

Create ongoing workplace mental health awareness campaigns, trainings, or workshops that educate employees about mental illness and encourage them to seek help when they need it.

Be proactive in preventing burnout

Burnout is a workplace issue, and employees are increasingly looking to their employers for solutions. Designing your workplace in a way that provides role clarity, realistic job demands, recognition, career development opportunities, and adequate resources is a good place to start. Also, encourage employees to take PTO, including for mental health reasons, as well as short breaks throughout the day.

Be flexible

In a Mental Health America survey, 56 percent of workers said having flexibility in their workday is the number-one way their employer could better support them. Allow employees to decide how to structure their day. When they’re feeling overwhelmed, consider making changes in work assignments, hours, deadlines, or working conditions, if possible.

Create an inclusive environment

A diverse and inclusive work environment can help prevent mental health problems. A few key steps include hiring a culturally diverse workforce, launching training programs to build cultural competency, and creating resource groups and community spaces that provide an outlet for connection.

Offer a comprehensive mental health benefit

The number-one way to improve mental health in the workplace is to invest in comprehensive benefits that meet your employees’ diverse needs. Most employees (80 percent) today say that when considering a new job, it’s at least somewhat important that the prospective employer offer mental health benefits.

When employees feel their companies support their mental health, they’re less likely to experience symptoms of mental illness, miss work, or underperform. They’re also more likely to talk about mental health and workplace concerns, feel satisfied with their job, and feel proud to work at their company.

In our new world of work, a baseline investment in an EAP, health plan, or mental health app isn’t enough. With these approaches, low utilization, long wait times, and other barriers keep people from accessing care that has a positive impact on their lives and ability to work.

To truly promote mental health in the workplace, the mental health benefits you offer should include:

• Support for the full spectrum of mental health needs, from day-to-day stress to depression, anxiety, and more complex conditions
• A diverse, vetted provider network that can meet the needs of Black, Indigenous, and people of color (BIPOC) and LGBTQIA+ employees
• A commitment to care approaches that have been researched and tested, with data to prove results
• Technology that makes care widely accessible in a variety of ways, such as video, telephone, live chat, and in-person

Lyra’s comprehensive mental health benefit helps employees and their families quickly and easily access high-quality care that transforms lives and bolsters companies’ bottom lines.

The time to invest in workplace mental health is now

The health of your organization relies on your commitment to workforce mental health. You have the power to change the conversation around mental health in the workplace by offering a truly comprehensive benefit that makes it easy for employees to access high-quality care when they need it.

It’s the right thing to do for your employees’ well-being. And it pays off in the long run.